Monday, October 24, 2011

Charlie Sheen Isn't Stupid: An Example of How Lawsuits Are Built

Tonight, Charlie Sheen will appear on ABC for a lengthy interview on its 20-20 show - though if you've been following the news, you've probably already heard Mr. Sheen's loud and long protests against the cancellation of his CBS comedy, Two and a Half Men.

If you think that Charlie Sheen is a nut for roaming around and pontificating to Piers Morgan (CNN), Howard Stern, the crew at Good Morning America, TMZ.com, - well, the list goes on and on (the Washington Post calls this his "media storm") -- then you'd be wrong. Wrong.

Because while some may think that Sheen is crazy, he may well be crazy like a fox. Why? From a legal perspective, Charlie Sheen is doing a fine job of getting positioned for a big, fat lawsuit where millions (if not billions) will be on the line.

Lawsuits are Strategically Built, They Don't Spring Up Fully Formed
All lawsuits arise from a formal pleading (the petition or complaint) being filed down at the courthouse with the appropriate clerk, the original being placed in the public record and then copies being given to those who have been sued through a procedure called "service of process." However, that lawsuit didn't just start that day or that week.

Lawsuits are prepared and planned and built for weeks or months before that filing occurs. Facts are gathered, legal research is done. Evidence is made ready through the gathering of documents and the accumulation of witness statements.

You get ready for the fight in an aggressive, thorough manner. The claims that appear in that first filing are supported by lots of hard work and shrewd planning.

All plaintiffs work with their attorneys in this process. They gather evidence. They position themselves for the fight. They are an integral part of the team. And, if they're wise, they work with the potential defendants in an attempt to negotiate a resolution of the controversy before the legal war in the courtroom begins.

Which is exactly what Charlie Sheen is doing. Consider these things that we know and what they may well mean:
1. Charlie Sheen is represented by the Los Angeles law firm of Lavely & Singer - and Radar Online has published a letter that Sheen's lawyers have sent to Warner Brothers and CBS warning that Sheen has legal claims - that Sheen considers himself to be legally wronged.

Translate this to: Sheen's lawyers have given legal notice that a lawsuit - based on contractual damages as well as personal injury - may be forthcoming. Sheen's pondering and perhaps planning litigation - here's his formal notice to the parties he's considering suing. He's letting them know he has legal representation and they are letting the potential defendants know what these legal claims are.

2. Charlie Sheen is doing things now to counter any defense that might be asserted by these defendants. He's doing drug tests in front of the media - blood, urine - and coming out clean.

Translate this to: evidence that Steen is not operating under the influence through lab tests taken before witnesses who can testify that the tests were not fixed. Evidence here, not some stunt.


Translate this to: Sheen is letting everyone knows he's ready to continue with his contractual duties. He's not breaching here.

4. Charlie Sheen is actively seeking other projects. Movies, talk shows, etc. These don't seem to be panning out according to media reports.

Translate this to: Sheen is investigating whether or not he has been harmed by the things that have been said about him - has he been professionally injured, has he been legally defamed?

Say what you want about Charlie Sheen. Hate his show, or like it. Disapprove of his lifestyle or revere him as the new Hugh Hefner -- bottom line, Sheen is exemplifying an involved plaintiff preparing for a legal war and there are lessons to learn here.

By Bryant Esquenazi on March 1, 2011 1:32 PM

No comments:

Post a Comment